15% TRICK OR TREAT DISCOUNT FOR 24 HOURS

Privada Cigar Club Reviews – From the World’s Most Exclusive Cigar Community

Every cigar tells a story and in Privada Cigar Club, our members are the storytellers. This is the most trusted source for cigar club reviews and boutique cigar ratings because every word you read comes from people who actually smoke the rare, aged, and small-batch cigars we release.

Here, you’ll find premium cigar reviews that dive into construction, burn, draw, and complex flavor transitions. You’ll see aged cigar testimonials from collectors who have waited years for the perfect moment to light up. And you’ll discover exclusive cigar feedback on blends that may never be produced again.

Whether you’re researching the best cigar subscription reviews before joining, or you’re a long-time member looking for the next must-smoke, this is your gateway to real experiences, shared by real cigar lovers, about cigars you simply cannot find anywhere else.

Based on 2170 reviews
86%
(1871)
10%
(221)
3%
(60)
1%
(11)
0%
(7)
R
Castle Grayskull
Ryan Adair

Received this in the Privada Club shipment. This cigar was so damn good, I quickly jumped on the site and ordered more to share with my son. Do yourself a favor and grab them while available.

A
Farm Rolled Grab Bags
Augustine Gonzales

I really enjoyed the grab bag and the extra love that came with it. Thanks a lot I appreciate it! Will order again. The Connecticut's are very good! Would love to get some more.

C
Padilla Italia Release
Carlos A Rivera

good smoke.

Very good cigar. pleasant to smoke, medium to full. will be getting some more.

I am glad I joined this fantastic club. I look forward to receiving the cigars each month. Great information is provided for each cigar, thanks to the included cards, which are excellent. Keep up the good work. Thanks.

R
Farm Rolled
Rory Chancy

Amazing cigars

B
Farm Rolled Grab Bags
Bobbie Strong

Husband loved them

It was one of the best Connecticut cigars I’ve had in awhile.

Excellent Cigars!
Excellent Service!
What more can you ask for???

PRIVADA is the new cigar standard!
Doc

G
Farm Rolled
George Blunt

Nice sticks

Not only do you get a cigar instead of paying for shipping, it’s always a mystery and that is half the fun! If you aren’t adding the free shipping cigar, you are doing it wrong.

Great club ! Thanks for opening it up to me when you did.

Smoking this cigar feels like sitting on a Puerto Rican veranda, sipping a fine Rum or a glass of wine, soaking in the island vibes. Then suddenly you realize- this cigar isn't just strong, It's a stealthy knock out. It's definitely not for beginners, but for the seasoned Aficionados, It's an unforgettable, smooth knockout with a distinct Boricua soul. A true ode to Puerto Rico's rich tobacco heritage. I'm in love with it.

J
Backdoor Buyer's Club
Justice Weingart

Great value here. Privada delivers again!

Top notch prompt customer service, Brian is always great to interact with! I dont say work with, this isn't work, this is a craft movement as he says, all of the interactions are a part of the experience, great cigars from a great group of people in a great community! We are Privada!! Glad to be back!!

S
Farm Rolled
Stephen

Always a pleasure to receive the farm rolled box. Great value!

Great cigars at a great price

D
Farm Rolled
Dwmetzgar

I was initially skeptical… first one I smoked was rough…. BUT, they turned out to be excellent smooth smokes. Great batch and with the $8 free shipping cigar it is the best deal on the planet.

Super creamy excellent morning smoke with coffee!

B
El Buble Aged 2+ Years
Bobby Nickels

i had this cigar 1 year ago and was not my favorite of the bunch.. had a few sitting in the humidor for an additional year plus. figured ill grab one and see if anything changed.... i must say off the first third.. No.. still very Herb noted cigar, no sweetness, not to much cream if at all. still the same really...if your looking for a creamy sweet cigar.. my suggestion is to skip this one., Imo. , very woody, cedarish, notes of herbs, not sweet at all..... smells good however dont think this will be my go to cigar anytime soon....... 90 min cigar because i had too... still 90 mins of me time and that i will not take back..... Privada thanks for the offering!!
greatly appreciated!! wont change a thing!!

Been in Club for 7 years. I can honestly say every cigar I have received from Club, Brian’s Box, and Farm Roll have been fabulous.

A
Damaged Cigars
Adam Leech

It seems like half the time I'm looking at it under a microscope to make sure the one I have is the damaged cigar. They're always smokable and rarely have enough of a defect to make them unenjoyable. Well worth the price.

Share Your Cigar Experience. Join the World’s Most Trusted Cigar Review Community

Above, you’ve explored hundreds of boutique cigar ratings and premium cigar reviews from smokers who understand that a great cigar is more than flavor, it’s an experience. Every member who leaves exclusive cigar feedback adds to the living archive of Privada Cigar Club, building a resource that guides collectors and newcomers alike.

When you post your own review, you contribute to the only database of aged cigar testimonials in the world backed by a true boutique cigar subscription. Did you love the complexity of a Nicaraguan puro? Did your smoke pair perfectly with vintage rum or barrel-proof bourbon? Did you find a cigar worth aging another decade? Your words could help someone else uncover their next favorite stick.

Privada is more than the best cigar subscription, it’s the heartbeat of rare cigar culture. This reviews page proves that every member is part of something historic: a global collective documenting the rarest, most exceptional cigars ever rolled.

Login

Forgot your password?

Don't have an account yet?
Create account